Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company

BestLink

AMB #: 000221 NAIC #: 13528 FEIN #: 350198580

Mailing Address
P.O. Box 2227
Fort Wayne, Indiana 46801

United States

Web: www.brotherhoodmutual.com

Phone: 260-482-8668

Fax: 260-483-7525

View Additional Address Information

Administrative Office
6400 Brotherhood Way
Fort Wayne, Indiana 46825
United States

Domiciliary Address
6400 Brotherhood Way
Fort Wayne, Indiana 46825
United States

Assigned to insurance companies that have, in our opinion, a good ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations.

View additional news, reports and products for this company.

Based on AM Best's analysis, 049398 - Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company is the AMB Ultimate Parent and identifies the topmost entity of the corporate structure. View a list of operating insurance entities in this structure.

Best's Credit Ratings

Financial Strength View Definition

Rating (Rating Category):	B++ (Good)
Outlook (or Implication):	Stable
Action:	Affirmed
Effective Date:	July 07, 2026
Initial Rating Date:	June 30, 1953

Long-Term Issuer Credit View Definition

Rating (Rating Category):	bbb+ (Good)
Outlook (or Implication):	Stable
Action:	Affirmed
Effective Date:	July 07, 2026
Initial Rating Date:	May 18, 2007

Financial Size Category View Definition

Financial Size Category:

IX (USD 250 Million to Less than 500 Million)

u Denotes Under Review Best's Rating

Best's Credit Rating Analyst

Rating Office: A.M. Best Rating Services, Inc.

Associate Director: Janet Hernandez

Director: Christopher Draghi, CPCU

Note: See the Disclosure information Form or Press Release below for the office and analyst at the time of the rating event.

Disclosure Information

Disclosure Information Form
View AM Best's Rating Disclosure Form

Press Release
AM Best Revises Issuer Credit Rating Outlook to Stable for Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
July 07, 2026

Rating History

A.M. Best has provided ratings & analysis on this company since 1953.

Financial Strength Rating

Effective Date	Rating
July 07, 2026	B++
May 07, 2025	B++
April 11, 2024	B++
March 14, 2023	A-
February 23, 2022	A-

Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating

Effective Date	Rating
July 07, 2026	bbb+
May 07, 2025	bbb+
April 11, 2024	bbb+
March 14, 2023	a-
February 23, 2022	a-

Best's Credit & Financial Reports

Best's Credit Report - financial data included in Best's Credit Report reflects the data used in determining the current credit rating(s).

Best's Credit Report - Archive - reports which were released prior to the current Best's Credit Report.

Best's Financial Report - financial data included in Best's Financial Report reflects the most current data available to AM Best, including updated financial exhibits and additional company information, and is available to subscribers of Best's Insurance Reports.

Best's Financial Report - Archive - reports which were released prior to the current Best's Financial Report.

View additional news, reports and products for this company.

Press Releases

Date	Title


Jul 07, 2026	AM Best Revises Issuer Credit Rating Outlook to Stable for Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Apr 11, 2024	AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Feb 02, 2021	AM Best Revises Outlooks to Negative for Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Jan 16, 2019	AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company